Sharia Series: Arranged, Forced, and Love Marriages
Marriage is a significant institution in Islam, emphasizing companionship, mutual respect, and familial ties. Many Muslims are aware of a well-known Hadith which refers to marriage for a Muslim fulfilling half of their religion.
Within Muslim communities, three primary types of marriage often arise: arranged marriages, forced marriages, and love marriages. As a family lawyer, understanding the distinctions between these types is crucial for appreciating the cultural and religious contexts in which they occur.
Arranged Marriage
An arranged marriage in Islam is usually characterised by the involvement of families in the selection of a spouse. Oftentimes the individuals to be wed are allowed agency to provide preferences to their family members with regards to characteristics they require of their spouse. This practice is deeply rooted in many cultures and aims to foster familial ties and ensure compatibility between the couple.
Key Features:
Parental Involvement: Families play a crucial role in introducing potential partners, often considering factors such as social status, education, and family values.
Consent: Islamic teachings emphasize that both parties must consent to the marriage. The Prophet Muhammad said, “A woman should not be married until she has given her consent.”
Compatibility: The goal is to find a partner with whom one shares mutual values and backgrounds, which can lead to a harmonious relationship.
Cultural Context: Arranged marriages can vary widely in their execution. In some cases, individuals may meet several potential partners before making a choice, while in others, the match may be more traditional and based on family lineage.
Forced Marriage
A forced marriage is very different from, but often confused with, an arranged marriage. This occurs when one or both parties are coerced into the union against their will. This practice is fundamentally incompatible with Islamic principles, which uphold individual autonomy and the importance of consent in marriage. A forced marriage will not be valid under Sharia law. Forced marriage is also a criminal offence in England and Wales, governed by the Anti-Social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act 2014. Protective measures are governed by the Family Law Act 1996 and the Forced Marriage (Civil Protection) Act 2007. The Court can issue a Forced Marriage Protection Order to protect an individual from being forced into a marriage. The Order can include requirements such as surrendering passports and preventing taking someone abroad.
Key Features:
Lack of Consent: Individuals in a forced marriage do not have the freedom to choose their partner. This can lead to emotional and psychological distress.
Cultural Misinterpretation: Some cultures may confuse arranged marriages with forced marriages, particularly when family pressure overrides individual choice.
Islamic Stance: Islam strictly prohibits forced marriages. The Quran states that both parties must consent freely and willingly, as highlighted in various hadiths.
Legal and Social Implications: Forced marriages can have serious legal consequences in England and Wales, with increasing recognition in many countries of the need to protect vulnerable individuals from coercion.
Love Marriage
A love marriage is based on the romantic affection and personal choice of the individuals involved. This form of marriage emphasises personal connection and emotional compatibility, aligning with the Islamic view of marriage as a partner. Within the Islamic community in England and Wales, love marriages are becoming increasingly more significant as opposed to arranged marriages. Perhaps with the introduction of Islamic dating apps it has become easier for Muslims to find their own life partners.
Key Features:
Mutual Affection: Love marriages often begin with a relationship built on mutual understanding and attraction.
Family Acceptance: While personal choice is paramount, families may still play a role in the union, as gaining familial approval can be important in many cultures.
Consent and Autonomy: Like arranged marriages, love marriages must also be consensual, aligning with Islamic teachings that emphasize the importance of choice in marital relationships.
Cultural Perspectives: In many contemporary Muslim societies, love marriages are increasingly accepted, reflecting changing attitudes towards personal freedom and the role of love in marriage.
Final Thoughts
Arranged marriages, forced marriages, and love marriages each reflect different cultural practices and interpretations within the Islamic context. They are often misunderstood and misrepresented, however it is important to understand which ‘type’ of marriage has taken place as this can have a significant impact on the legal recognition of the marriage. While arranged marriages can align with Islamic principles when based on consent and mutual respect, forced marriages violate the core tenets of the faith. Love marriages, grounded in personal choice, also hold a valid place within the broader framework of Islamic teachings.
Understanding these distinctions helps illuminate the complexities of marriage in Islamic communities and the importance of consent, respect, and mutual understanding in fostering successful unions. As cultural norms evolve, the new generation of Muslims are utilising technological advances to find partners. These marriage types continue to adapt, emphasising the balance between tradition and individual rights.
Islamic marriages within the English legal system can be a complex, requiring specialist advice. Lawyers within the Irwin Mitchell Religious and Cultural Team of Excellence deal with these topics daily and can provide expert advice.
Find out more about our international family law team.
